Overblog Follow this blog
Edit post Administration Create my blog
March 1 2013 6 01 /03 /March /2013 04:47

Obama Administration Joins Legal Fight Against California Gay Marriage Ban

PHOTO: Prop 8 opponents

 

 

The Department of Justice filed a brief today in the case of a controversial California ballot initiative that defines marriage as between one man and one woman, asking the Supreme Court to affirm a lower court decision that struck down the measure, known as Proposition 8.

 

The brief marked the first time that the Obama administration has come out in court against Prop 8 and the first time it has argued against state gay marriage ban before the Supreme Court.

 

The administration's argument also could reverberate beyond California. If the Supreme Court accepts the arguments in the brief, it could lay the groundwork toward undermining laws against gay marriage in several other states.

 

"The exclusion of gay and lesbian couples from marriage does not substantially further any important governmental interest. Proposition 8 thus violates equal protection," wrote Solicitor General Donald B. Verrilli Jr. in a "friend of the court" brief filed in favor of gay and lesbian couples challenging Prop 8.

 

Now that it has filed a Supreme Court amicus brief, the Obama administration most likely will be granted time to actually argue its position in front of the justices. When the government files an amicus brief in an important case, it is normally granted time to argue.

 

A statement on behalf of ProtectMarriage.com, the proponent of Prop 8, described the Obama administration's decision to weigh in both "unprecedented" and "hardly surprising, but nevertheless disturbing."

 

"In his first term as president, Obama clearly stated that Americans can choose a special designation of marriage between man and woman, and that supporters of traditional marriage can hold that position without animus," said the statement by Andy Pugno, general counsel for ProtectMarriage.com. "He later remarked that it would be a 'mistake' to make the debate over redefining marriage into a federal issue.

 

"Yet today," the statement added, "by stating that the traditional definition of marriage is rooted only in irrational prejudice, the president has impugned the motives and actions of millions of Californians and turned his back on society's long-standing interest in both mothers and fathers raising the next generation."

 

Thomas Peters, communications director for the National Organization for Marriage, another gay marriage opponent, invoked California's voters in saying the group expected the court to uphold the law.

 

"NOM expects the Supreme Court to exonerate the votes of over 7 million Californians to protect marriage," said Peters. "The president is clearly fulfilling a campaign promise to wealthy gay marriage donors. There is no right to redefine marriage in our Constitution."

 

However, referring to proponents of the voter-approved measure who are defending it in court, Verrilli wrote, "Petitioners contend that Proposition 8 serves an interest in returning the issue of marriage to the democratic process, but use of a voter initiative to promote democratic self-governance cannot save a law like Proposition 8 that would otherwise violate equal protection."

 

In Depth: Obama's Prop 8 Decision


The Obama administration brief noted that California extends all of the rights and responsibilities of marriage to gay and lesbians, but forbids them the designation of "marriage."

 

That circumstance "particularly undermines the justifications for Proposition 8," Verrilli wrote.

 

While the brief fell short of calling for a fundamental right to marriage under the Constitution, it suggested that if the court were to agree with the administration's position, gay marriage laws in seven other states could be in jeopardy. Those states are Delaware, Hawaii, Illinois, Nevada, New Jersey, Oregon and Rhode Island.

 

"The brief pays closest attention to California and the other seven states that grant same-sex couples all the rights and responsibilities of marriage but insist on denying them the favored name," said Jane S. Schacter, a professor at Stanford Law School. "But it advocates that the court adopt a much tougher, more skeptical approach to any state law that denies same-sex couples the right to marry.

Share this post

Repost 0
Published by laptopbattery- Laptop Battery Blog - life - in News
write a comment

comments

Overview

  • : laptopbattery-homes Laptop Battery Blog - life's name
  • laptopbattery-homes Laptop Battery Blog - life's name
  • : laptop battery blog - We sell high quality and cheap laptop batteries Replacement for ACER, DELL, TOSHIBA, HP ,SONY, COMPAQ laptop battery and so on. We are working hard to make your online shopping easy, fast, convenient and safe. We are always here to serve your needs
  • Contact

Search

About...

www.laptopbatteryhomes.com is a manufacturer & distributor specializing in laptop batteries helps you find the best quality lowest priced batteries. we carries over over 3000 replacement batteries, AC adapters for over 140 notebook manufacturers. Our product range include replacement computer batteries for most major laptop brands, including Dell, Acer,Apple, Compaq/HP, IBM/Lenovo, Fujitsu, Gateway, Sony and Toshiba.

www.laptopbatteryhomes.com is an online retailer and wholesale of laptop batteries. Our goal is to deliver the highest capacity battery at a great price, while providing an efficient and secure shopping experience. Our main focus is to provide our customers with excellent service , we offer a hassle-free no questions asked 30-day money back guarantee and all our products come with a 1 year warranty. We are confident that you will be completely satisfied with our products and service. If you don't find the product listed here or you want wholesale more products, please e-mail us.

We are an experienced group of internet sellers. All of our batteries are directly purchased by various reputable manufacturers throughout the world. They have passed strict quality assurance procedures such as CE, UL, and/or ISO9001/9002 certification.

Last Articles

Links